When it comes to training collars, two common options are the leather training collar and the prong collar. While both serve a purpose, they are vastly different in function, application, and suitability for different levels of training experience. Let’s break down the key differences and when to use each tool.
1. Prong Collar: A Tool for Experienced Trainers
A prong collar is designed as a precision tool. When used correctly, it applies pressure evenly around the dog’s neck to provide immediate correction. However, it’s not a beginner-friendly tool. Many people misuse prong collars by applying excessive force or using them as a primary method of stopping unwanted behavior without first teaching the dog proper leash manners.
-
Not for beginners – If you haven’t trained with a prong collar before, it’s easy to misuse it.
-
Requires skill – Prong collars work best for finishing work, refining obedience, and reinforcing advanced training.
-
Temporary control – When used incorrectly, a dog may only respond to the collar while it’s on. The moment it’s removed, they may revert to their old behavior.
A common issue with prong collars is that they can fail if not properly fitted. Prong collars rely on interlocking links, and under heavy strain (such as a reactive dog pulling hard), these links can pop open unexpectedly. If this happens, your dog could break free, potentially putting them in a dangerous situation.
2. Leather Training Collar: A Beginner-Friendly Alternative
Unlike the prong collar, the leather training collar is a much simpler, more forgiving tool. It is designed for all levels of training, from beginner to advanced, and provides a safe and effective way to communicate with your dog.
-
Ideal for new trainers – Easy to use and provides consistent feedback.
-
Durable & fail-proof – Unlike prong collars, which can pop open, a leather training collar is one solid piece that will never fail under pressure.
-
Even pressure distribution – The collar contracts around the neck to create an effective point of contact, rather than sharp pressure points.
-
Sits low on the neck – Unlike prong collars, which sit high on the neck near the skull, the leather training collar rides lower, giving a different type of feedback that’s comfortable for the dog.
The leather training collar is also more versatile than a prong collar. It can be used for basic obedience training, loose-leash walking, and corrective training without needing excessive force or risk of injury.
3. Prong Collars Sit High – Leather Collars Sit Low
Another major difference is how these two collars are positioned on the dog:
-
Prong Collar: Sits high on the neck, right under the ears, applying precise correction.
-
Leather Training Collar: Sits low behind the ID collar, offering a natural, gentle way to communicate with your dog without excessive force.
This lower position provides a unique contact point that many dogs have never experienced, making it easier to guide and correct behavior without the risk of injury or discomfort.
4. Long-Term Durability and Reliability
One of the biggest drawbacks of a prong collar is its potential failure. Even when properly secured, prong collars are designed to hook together like a chain link, meaning they can easily come apart under stress.
On the other hand, a leather training collar is nearly indestructible. Made from thick, high-quality saddle skirting leather, it will last a lifetime with proper care. Whether you're training a small Springer Spaniel or a massive 200-pound Newfoundland, this collar will hold up under any conditions.
5. Making the Right Choice
If you're a professional trainer or have extensive experience using a prong collar, it may be a useful tool in specific situations. However, for most dog owners, the leather training collar is the safer, more reliable choice. It eliminates common issues like tool failure, improper use, and excessive force while offering superior control and communication with your dog.
Get Started with a Leather Training Collar Today
If you're looking for a durable, effective training tool that works for any dog, grab a leather training collar from our website today. We also offer tutorial videos and an online training community to help you get the most out of your collar.
Still have questions? Send us a DM on Instagram or TikTok, or email us at bestdogs@gmail.com or jared@bestgundogs.com. We’re here to help!
Happy training!